Final judgment in the light of inclusion

If all people are already reconciled to God in Christ, then why a final judgment at Jesus' return? And why, as a result of that judgment, will God cast out some if all are already included?

We note Scripture's use of "casting into outer darkness," "separating sheep from goats" and similar phrases to speak of circumstances related to final judgment. We acknowledge that such phrases are symbolic. But symbolic of what?


In answering this and related questions, I've found help from Robert Farrar Capon in his book, "Kingdom, Grace, Judgment" (Eerdmans, 2002, see book cover above). Capon analyzes Jesus' parables, which speak frequently of judgment and hell. Following are illustrative quotes related to these topics. I recommend a careful reading of the whole book for the details, including Capon's careful scriptural argumentation. You may also be interested in reading a recent blog from Baxter Kruger on the same topic: click here.

-Ted Johnston
The [final] judgment occurs only after the general resurrection of the dead. And since the resurrection of the dead (of the just and the unjust alike) is something that happens to them solely by virtue of Jesus' resurrection...everything that happens after the second coming of Jesus - judgment, heaven and even hell - happens within the triumphantly reconciling power of his death and resurrection. We simply don't know how or to what degree that power affects the eschatological situation. Take, for example, the question of whether we are in a position to discuss the meaning or even the possibility of ultimate human rejection of the reconciliation. To be sure, Scripture says clearly enough that the sovereign, healing power of Jesus can and will be refused by some. I have no problem with that. What I do object to, however, are the hell-enthusiasts who act as if God's whole New Testament method of dealing with evil will, in the last day, simply go back to some Old Testament "square one" - as if Jesus hadn't done a blessed or merciful thing in between...Admittedly, the Bible talks about all sorts of creatures going to hell. But my point is that if they do go, they go even there in the power of a resurrection by which God in Christ has reconciled all things to himself, hell included. There is no one anywhere in the final scheme of things who is floating around in his own old unrisen state. Resurrection is not a reward for the chosen few; it is the only game there in in the whole eschatological town (p. 96).

Doesn't Scripture say that there will be some (or even many) who will reject the reconciliation? Of course it does. But the very hell of hell lies precisely in the fact that its inhabitants will be insisting on a perpetual rejection of an equally perpetual gift. It will be an eternal struggle to escape from the grip of a love that will never let them go. And for that everlasting stand-off, I think, there is not a word in Scripture that is too strong: not the "fire that is not quenched," not the "worm that dieth not," not the "outer darkness," not the "bottomless pit," not the "weeping and gnashing of teeth" - and certainly not the utterly fruitless "second death" (p. 117).

Notice something peculiar about that [last] day. It occurs...after the general resurrection: every last person who arrives at it arrives in the power of Jesus' reconciliation. The judgment, therefore, is first of all the announcement not of vindictiveness but of vindication. Everyone who comes before the Judge has already been reconciled by the dying and rising of the Judge. The only sentence to be pronounced, as far as the Judge himself is concerned, is a sentence to life, and life abundant. Someone once said, "The world God loves is the world he sees in his only-begotten Son." If that is true, it means that at the last day, the whole world - the all that Jesus, in his being lifted up, has drawn to himself - is accepted in the Beloved. No one has to accept that acceptance, of course. It is entirely possible, both humanly and scripturally speaking, for anyone to thumb his nose at the reconciliation and try to go it on his own forever. And it is totally certain that if anyone wants to indulge in that kind of behavior, there is no possibility of keeping such a party pooper at the marriage supper of the Lamb. Hell is the only option for the finally recalcitrant. But note well that nobody goes to hell because he had a rotten track record in the world - any more than anyone goes to heaven because he had a good one....We are not judged by our previous performances...rather, we are judged by what Jesus did for us on the cross....Both heaven and hell are populated entirely and only by forgiven sinners. Hell is just a courtesy for those who insist they want no part of forgiveness (pp. 131-132).

Question: ...Do you actually mean that there's nobody at the Last Judgment who hasn't been given the righteousness of Christ? Answer: Yes, that's exactly what I mean. Question: Then how do some of them get judged [as evil]?...Answer: Because even though they've got his righteousness, they've decided they don't like it; they can't stand the thought of not being accepted on their very own personal merit (pp. 134-135).

A whole New Jerusalem [will be] populated by nothing but sinners whose citizenship is based on nothing but their acceptance of forgiveness. If anybody doesn't want to be there on that basis, he can, quite literally, just get the hell out (p. 136).

Hell is only for those who insist on finding their life outside of Jesus' death (p. 232).

He who was sent not to judge the world but to save the world (John 3:17) will not count our records against us. What the Son will offer the Father at the last day is the silence of his death on the subject of our sins and the power of his resurrection on the subject of our life (p. 282).

The judgement finally pronounced will be based only on our acceptance or rejection of our resurrection from the dead. The last judgment will vindicate everybody, for the simple reason that everybody will have passed the only test God has, namely, that they are all dead and risen in Jesus. Nobody will be kicked out for having a rotten life, because nobody there will have any life by the life of Jesus (p. 301).

For Jesus came to raise the dead. He did not come to reward the rewardable, improve the improvable, or correct the correctable; he came simply to be the resurrection and the life of those who will take their stand on a death he can use instead of on a life he cannot (p. 317).

The resurrection of the dead...is not the return of corpses to their previous living state; it is an eternally new creation arising out of an equally eternal death - just as, if you will, our old, natural existence is a perpetual, moment-by-moment emergence out of an equally perpetual nothing (p. 324).

The church, by and large, has always been more receptive to judgment-as-settling-scores than to judgement as proceeding out of, and in accordance with, the reconciling grace of resurrection. Christian preachers regularly blow the Gospel of grace clean out of the water with sermons that make reward and punishment, not resurrection with its sovereign pardon, the touchstone of judgment...[Jesus] has taken away all the sins of the world and...has accordingly, solved all the problems he once had with sin....He "did not come to judge the world but to save the world" (John 12:47)..."There is therefore now no condemnation to those who are in Christ Jesus" (Rom. 8:1) (pp. 350-351).

The judgment, is precisely one of forgiveness, of a saving grace that works by death and resurrection....The action of Jesus in his passion - his saving, judging inaction, if you will - governs everything (p. 352).

Jesus must not be read as having baited us with grace only to clobber us in the end with law. For as the death and resurrection of Jesus were accomplished once and for all, so the grace that reigns by those mysteries reigns eternally - even in the thick of judgment....Inclusion before exclusion is the chief interpretative principle of [Jesus'] parables of judgment. As a general rule - and especially in his specific parables of judgment - Jesus is at pains to show that no one is kicked out who wasn't already in....Judgment...never comes until after acceptance: grace remains forever the sovereign consideration. The difference between the blessed and the cursed is one thing and one thing only: the blessed accept their acceptance and the cursed reject it; but the acceptance is already in place for both groups before either does anything about it. To put it another way, heaven is populated by nothing but forgiven sinners and hell is populated by nothing but forgiven sinners: the Lamb of God takes away the sins of the kosmos, not just of the chosen few (John 1:29); Jesus said "I, if I be lifted up, will draw all to me (John 12:32). The difference between heaven and hell, accordingly, is simply that those in heaven accept the endless forgiveness, while those in hell reject it. Indeed, the precise hell of hell is its endless refusal to open the door to the reconciled and reconciling party that stands forever on its porch and knocks, equally endlessly, for permission to bring in the Super of the Lamb (Rev. 3:20) (pp. 356-357).

The mystery manifested in Jesus' death forgives us now because it is as present now as it was on the cross; the mystery manifested in his resurrection restores us now because it is as present now as it was when he left the tomb; and the mystery manifested in his judgment vindicates us now because it is as present now as it will be when he appears in glory (p. 410).

Comments

  1. Thank you Ted for sharing this information about Judgment. It is good to ponder this subject. And as I read this material, a sentence jumped out at me. It is:

    “Jesus must not be read as having baited us with grace only to clobber us in the end with law.”

    Yet this is precisely the impression the modern faith is leaving in so many minds. The resulting feelings of condemnation and guilt are truly destructive to having confidence in God to deliver humans into eternal realms with Him.

    When are we (meaning modern Christianity) going to learn that law has no place in our Christian life and standing with God? Only Jesus does. This all reminds me of what Paul says about Israel:

    Rom 10:1-4--Brothers, my heart's desire and prayer to God for the Israelites is that they may be saved. For I can testify about them that they are zealous for God, but their zeal is not based on knowledge. Since they did not know the righteousness that comes from God and sought to establish their own, they did not submit to God's righteousness. Christ is the end of the law so that there may be righteousness for everyone who believes. (NIV)

    And Paul also says:

    Gal 3:23-29--Before this faith came, we were held prisoners by the law, locked up until faith should be revealed. So the law was put in charge to lead us to Christ that we might be justified by faith. Now that faith has come, we are no longer under the supervision of the law. You are all sons of God through faith in Christ Jesus, for all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ. There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus. If you belong to Christ, then you are Abraham's seed, and heirs according to the promise. (NIV)

    To me, this done deal faith is a great joy of Trinitarian Theology.

    The best to you always!

    J. Richard Parker

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great post and quotes Ted! I cannot recommend or second the Gospel encouragement in this book enough!

    I am happy to see every Pastor receive a copy, and receive another myself to share with someone else!! :-)It sits at arms reach in my study for a quick study before preaching any parable! His attention to detail regarding the original language of the written scriptures is phenomenal!

    Robert has taught me personally to take seriously the whole of scripture, to see it all in the Light of Jesus (Who is the Creator, Sustainer and Resurrection of all things), and to LAUGH!!! He has a great share in the Holy Spirit's humor!!

    I will be forever grateful for his friendship, guidance and inspiration in the Triune God! Get and read this book as soon as you can, especially if you enjoy laughing in the Good News!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ted, Great comments from Robert Capon's book. After I bought this book last year it answered so many questions that people asked about this or that verse which at first seemed to go against Trinitarian Theology. Capon's humor is unique and refreshing.

    Thanks for posting these comments on Judgement.

    Paul Kurts

    ReplyDelete
  4. All the dead will rise again, whether they are good or evil, because of what Christ has done :) Those who accept their acceptance will enter into the joy of their master. Those who reject it will suffer the "second death." If I recall correctly, our GCI doctrine does not have a categorical statement on the immortality of the soul.

    ReplyDelete
  5. To read an article from GCI regarding the soul, go to http://www.gci.org/spiritual/soulspirit

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts

Can people get out of hell?

Does everyone have the Holy Spirit?

The missional character of the church

Theology and Biblical Studies - What's the Difference?

The nature of our union with Christ

Ministry: sharing in what Jesus is doing

Question on John 3:36

Torrance on the church and its mission

What about mission?

The link between theology and mission